Petsy – Reduced CAC, Grew Customer Base

The Challenge
Petsy came to Crafeed with a clear goal: grow their customer base while keeping acquisition costs lean in an increasingly competitive pet care market.
We started by overhauling their paid ads strategy—shifting from broad targeting to niche, high-intent audience segments like first-time pet parents, breed-specific communities, and repeat buyers of essentials. From there, we launched targeted campaigns for best-selling SKUs like supplements, grooming products, and treats, each backed by tailored creatives and sharp, benefit-led copy.
Our creative direction leaned into real pet-parent moments—relatable, fun, and emotionally resonant. We also built retargeting flows based on browsing behavior and replenishment cycles to drive repeat purchases.
We started by overhauling their paid ads strategy—shifting from broad targeting to niche, high-intent audience segments like first-time pet parents, breed-specific communities, and repeat buyers of essentials. From there, we launched targeted campaigns for best-selling SKUs like supplements, grooming products, and treats, each backed by tailored creatives and sharp, benefit-led copy.
Our creative direction leaned into real pet-parent moments—relatable, fun, and emotionally resonant. We also built retargeting flows based on browsing behavior and replenishment cycles to drive repeat purchases.
The Result?
Lower CACs, a significant bump in ROAS, and a rapidly growing community of loyal, repeat pet parents—all while strengthening Petsy's position as a go-to brand in the category.